ZR-1 Net Registry Forums

ZR-1 Net Registry Forums (http://zr1.net/forum/index.php)
-   C4 ZR-1 General Postings (http://zr1.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   Just Failed CA Smog. Now what? (http://zr1.net/forum/showthread.php?t=24618)

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 04:12 PM

Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
I bought my Z just over a year ago. Presumably it would have had to pass smog at that time. This time, everything passed except for NOX. Max for the 15MPH test is 545 PPM. My Z measured 587 PPM. The 25MPH test passed with 459 PPM. The Max is 502 PPM. The car is stock except for a KnN filter. I just went through some of the CA smog related threads and there seem to be folks who got a measurement in the 200s. In this thread by Z51JEFF, it looks like he passed by replacing his O2 sensors. Is this what I should try? If so, does anyone know what model and where I can get them and how many? Is there any way to tell after replacing the sensors whether it will work short of taking another smog test? Thanks!

KILLSHOTS 02-04-2015 04:37 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Did you have the power key in the FULL position during the test? If so, you may want to switch to NORMAL and run the test again. Ask me how I know.

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 04:40 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KILLSHOTS (Post 219522)
Did you have the power key in the FULL position during the test? If so, you may want to switch to NORMAL and run the test again. Ask me how I know.

Nope. I had the key in my pocket.

KILLSHOTS 02-04-2015 04:46 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Okiedoke (Post 219523)
Nope. I had the key in my pocket.

Nuts! Too bad it couldn't be something so simple. Good luck.

We Gone 02-04-2015 05:13 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Do you have the stock prom? Jerry's sells the O2's. Will the testers in Calf. let you run the test in a test mode to see if it will pass after you change the O2's?

mike100 02-04-2015 06:12 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
additional ignition timing would elevate NOx, but usually the port throttle closed timing map at the lower rev ranges doesn't deviate from stock much on some tunes.

If the other numbers were looking good except for NOx you surely need new O2 sensors. Cleaned my car right up. I will need to see your exact results for a more specific diagnosis though. Another easy fix is if you have a bad vacuum leak under the plenum somewhere (you can tell by a high idle).

I got the oxygen sensors from O'Reillys- they have the proper length 3 conductor wire harnesses.

5ABI VT 02-04-2015 06:21 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Was the car hot when tested? have you given it a good run @ wot beforehand and clean oil? My SS failed ever so slightly.. I gave it balls to the wall for 15 mins and came back and it passed with flying colors.

Coupe89 02-04-2015 06:48 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
First time I tried to pass smog. Failed 3 times. Changed Eprom/Chip. Passed.

Last year I failed too many times. lol

Changed out the O2's. Picked up a pair of Bosch at the local parts store. Failed
Had to change out a bad injector it had 8.8 ohm's. Failed.
Then shop noticed the key in full power. They switched the key and passed. For got about the key after I changed out the injectors.

15-518 25-452

My shop suggested to change out the cats.

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 07:06 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by We Gone (Post 219527)
Do you have the stock prom? Jerry's sells the O2's. Will the testers in Calf. let you run the test in a test mode to see if it will pass after you change the O2's?

AFAIK, it's the stock prom. I haven't touched it at least. I doubt the tester will do a test pass. I do get a second official attempt for free within 30 days though.

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 07:38 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mike100 (Post 219533)
If the other numbers were looking good except for NOx you surely need new O2 sensors. Cleaned my car right up. I will need to see your exact results for a more specific diagnosis though.

Yes. All of the other numbers looked good. Here's the report:

http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d1...pschga0cwq.jpg


Quote:

Originally Posted by mike100 (Post 219533)
Another easy fix is if you have a bad vacuum leak under the plenum somewhere (you can tell by a high idle).

Now that you mention it, I haven't heard that clicking sound indicative of a vacuum leak when I start the engine in a long time. How high is considered a high idle?

Quote:

Originally Posted by mike100 (Post 219533)
I got the oxygen sensors from O'Reillys- they have the proper length 3 conductor wire harnesses.

I looked up both O'Reilly and Jerry's and found the following sensors:

1) O'Reilly: Bosch - Oxygen Sensor - Part#13077 ($45.99)
2) O'Reilly: Bosch - Universal Oxygen Sensor - Part#15726 ($57.99)
3) Jerry's: Delphi - Oxygen Sensor - OEM? GM PN 10137641 ($47.75)
4) Jerry's: Denso - Oxygen Sensor - GM PN 10137641 ($59.75)

Would all these work? Which is the preferred part?

Is this something I can easily swap out or should I take it to my mechanic?

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 07:42 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 5ABI VT (Post 219535)
Was the car hot when tested? have you given it a good run @ wot beforehand and clean oil? My SS failed ever so slightly.. I gave it balls to the wall for 15 mins and came back and it passed with flying colors.

It was about a 10 minute drive from work to the smog check station. Half local half freeway. I had the power key out. It's been around 2500 miles since my last oil change.

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 07:48 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Coupe89 (Post 219536)
First time I tried to pass smog. Failed 3 times. Changed Eprom/Chip. Passed.

Last year I failed too many times. lol

Changed out the O2's. Picked up a pair of Bosch at the local parts store. Failed
Had to change out a bad injector it had 8.8 ohm's. Failed.
Then shop noticed the key in full power. They switched the key and passed. For got about the key after I changed out the injectors.

15-518 25-452

My shop suggested to change out the cats.

Is there a limit to how many times CA allows you to fail or can you try as many times as you need? My registration renewal deadline is 3/8/2015. Does that mean I need to pass before this date?

Coupe89 02-04-2015 07:50 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Pay the registration before 3-8-15.
Dont want to get dinged on the late reg. Cal DMV wants there money....
My reg was up in Feb 2014 passed in Jul 2014

Coupe89 02-04-2015 07:51 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
No limit.... I think mine failed 4 or 5 times before it passed.

https://scontent-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hpho...03&oe=554923EE

https://scontent-b.xx.fbcdn.net/hpho...40&oe=55542239

Coupe89 02-04-2015 08:01 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
The O2 sensors.

the drive side is easy.
This is what I used to get the passenger side one off.
https://fbcdn-sphotos-f-a.akamaihd.n...86ae497676f3a9

5ABI VT 02-04-2015 08:06 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Okiedoke (Post 219540)
It was about a 10 minute drive from work to the smog check station. Half local half freeway. I had the power key out. It's been around 2500 miles since my last oil change.

The hotter the combustion temps are the better it will be on emissions. flip that power key and nail it a few times to heat it up and clean it out. Drive it around for 15-20 minutes with a few wot and take it hot to the test. I know you probably don't want to chance it on that but if they'll retest for free im fairly certain it would be enough to pass was for me. Oh and also the catalytic converters work better when hotter too so that may be all it needs.

Okiedoke 02-04-2015 09:15 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Coupe89 (Post 219544)
The O2 sensors.

the drive side is easy.
This is what I used to get the passenger side one off.

I found a couple of threads here and here about replacing the passenger side sensor.

Ummm...here comes a dumb question...where are the sensors located? Would I be able to find a diagram in the FSM?

Coupe89 02-04-2015 09:20 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Before the cats on my 90

Drivers side.
https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.n...53a3629892c296
Passenger Side (From the bottom) best pic I have....
https://fbcdn-sphotos-e-a.akamaihd.n...8753fd83bc399d

mike100 02-04-2015 09:30 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
I have the $45 Bosch ones from the parts store. They have been thru two smog test cycles now and pass. The originals were German made (also Bosch), but these are of US manufacture. One of the ones i got from Jerry a couple of years back had awfully short leads...I don't know if he is selling a different one now.

the o2's might clean up the low speed hydrocarbons a little too. They don't last forever. For NOx they have to be dead accurate as the sensitivity to lean or rich conditions elevate that gas quite rapidly. I'm sure you'll do better after you swap them for new.

mike100 02-04-2015 09:37 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 5ABI VT (Post 219545)
The hotter the combustion temps are the better it will be on emissions. ... Oh and also the catalytic converters work better when hotter too so that may be all it needs.

The cats need to be hot and the coolant up to temp (so it doesn't run rich), but hotter combustion, extra ign timing, lugging in gears at low rpm etc will spike the oxides of nitrogens thru the roof. If anything, run with a chip made to be all stock except for the part where it turns the cooling fans on at 205 degrees (instead of the factory 228 deg F). high combustion temps bad, high catalyst temps good.

Basically pinging is the ultimate NOx production condition. egr normally blows a puff of dirty air right when you crack the throttle to keep combustion temp below the threshold for nox. but of course the early cars have 11:1 compression and no egr.

Franke 02-04-2015 11:39 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
I agree with Z51Jeff and Mike100. I had the NOX issue too. Everthing passed except for that on the IM240 test. I found out that I had a lazy O2 sensor on the left side by using my Mastertech 3100 to watch the voltage swing. Replaced the O2's and passed. The new results were about 40% lower. I used the Bosch ones.

tf95ZR1 02-04-2015 11:55 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
I just saw this thread. I feel for you, OkDok!
I had the same problem passing CA smog with my Z.
All the recs already given are GREAT ideas.
I did them all (and some others!) to jump through
the hoops to finally get it to legitimately pass the sniffer.
Let me know if you want to talk privately....

PS: Some of the steps you do, like new O2 sensors, oil change
you can think of as general maintenance for an (old) car anyway.
What's a better word than "old"?

mgbrv8 02-05-2015 10:55 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Move to Texas :-)

tf95ZR1 02-05-2015 02:25 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
What's really frustrating is that the pass levels are much tougher now
than when the car was originally designed and built. So how are we
supposed to clean them up? In their minds, this is how they get rid of
the "smog machines".

I agree that the air is MUCH better now than in the 70's, so there has
to be a comprimise. As others have said, if a stock Z is running (really)
well, it should pass, maybe with a few changes/tricks.
With mods is a different story.

HAWAIIZR-1 02-06-2015 12:42 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
I have not had my "Welcome to California" smog testing yet. I guess I am too scared to find out. Actually have not had any time to attempt registering the car in this great State. I'm considering buying a nice, stock, low mileage ZR-1 and getting rid of mine...we'll see. Thanks for sharing all the tips and tricks and I will see if I can pass one day.

Best wishes to the OP.

Z51JEFF 02-06-2015 12:45 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
After you fail a few times you will be instructed to take the car to a referee station. This is a State owned facility,this place will make a decision as to weather the car will not pass,pass the car with an exemption or not sure after that,I couldn't get a straight answer out the guy when I there a few years ago. I got a little help from our friend in Ill when it comes to passing the test. Is it legal,I could care less. Ca has dropped the max limits on the Nox levels from 702 in 2008 down to 502 in 2014. Replacing the O2 sensors in not an easy job,at least getting one of the plugs in. I had o jump through hoops to get a bone stock 91 to pass with 20,000 original miles. What really suck,my car at 6000 original miles wouldn't pass today. I can help with the smog issue if needed.

HAWAIIZR-1 02-06-2015 01:07 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Z51JEFF (Post 219629)
After you fail a few times you will be instructed to take the car to a referee station. This is a State owned facility,this place will make a decision as to weather the car will not pass,pass the car with an exemption or not sure after that,I couldn't get a straight answer out the guy when I there a few years ago. I got a little help from our friend in Ill when it comes to passing the test. Is it legal,I could care less. Ca has dropped the max limits on the Nox levels from 702 in 2008 down to 502 in 2014. Replacing the O2 sensors in not an easy job,at least getting one of the plugs in. I had o jump through hoops to get a bone stock 91 to pass with 20,000 original miles. What really suck,my car at 6000 original miles wouldn't pass today. I can help with the smog issue if needed.

Geeez, maybe I should look at the 68 Convertible instead if I plan to live in Cali for a long time? I'm starting to think my car with the Stage I cams will never pass. Thanks for sharing. Now I see why the locals say the "SMOG Nazis"!

-=Jeff=- 02-06-2015 08:03 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HAWAIIZR-1 (Post 219632)
Geeez, maybe I should look at the 68 Convertible instead if I plan to live in Cali for a long time? I'm starting to think my car with the Stage I cams will never pass. Thanks for sharing. Now I see why the locals say the "SMOG Nazis"!

Locals.. heck I call the Cali Smog people that here in Chicago... Meanign they are well known as Smog Nazis outside of the Peoples Republic of Kalifornia

mike100 02-06-2015 11:13 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
What happens in CA won't necessarily stay in CA. The above examples of lowered NOx levels on our emissions tests come from what I believe were EPA limits that kicked in during 2012 or so from some law passed back in the 90's setting tiers to be met at certain future dates. We just happen to follow that trend (or actually set them in many cases that the EPA adopts later). What worries me is if they can/will lower them any lower knowing full well our older cars were designed to meet limits of the day, not modern ones.

As it sits now...big deal, you can definitely pass the testing- it is just that oxygen sensors don't work that well when they are 20 years old- you gotta get new ones. The problem is not clean tailpipes, but the rigid visual in this state.

HAWAIIZR-1 02-07-2015 07:58 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by -=Jeff=- (Post 219640)
Locals.. heck I call the Cali Smog people that here in Chicago... Meanign they are well known as Smog Nazis outside of the Peoples Republic of Kalifornia

I understand what you mean. The only other SMOG state I lived in was Connecticut about 15 years ago. Back then it seemed I just tested because I had too and routine, but had an issue passing. The car would have to be a POS and was running very poorly it seemed.

HAWAIIZR-1 02-07-2015 08:01 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mike100 (Post 219650)
What happens in CA won't necessarily stay in CA. The above examples of lowered NOx levels on our emissions tests come from what I believe were EPA limits that kicked in during 2012 or so from some law passed back in the 90's setting tiers to be met at certain future dates. We just happen to follow that trend (or actually set them in many cases that the EPA adopts later). What worries me is if they can/will lower them any lower knowing full well our older cars were designed to meet limits of the day, not modern ones.

As it sits now...big deal, you can definitely pass the testing- it is just that oxygen sensors don't work that well when they are 20 years old- you gotta get new ones. The problem is not clean tailpipes, but the rigid visual in this state.

I can see that I will have to try to get you to help me to pass when the time comes. I have not even looked into all the stuff I have to replace to pass visual since no C.A.R.B. approved stuff. I did buy a stock air cleaner so far and exhaust manifolds/cats from a 95 take off with 2K miles.

-=Jeff=- 02-07-2015 08:06 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Off topic:

Hawaii, when did you relocate to Cali? I must have missed that

HAWAIIZR-1 02-07-2015 09:18 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by -=Jeff=- (Post 219732)
Off topic:

Hawaii, when did you relocate to Cali? I must have missed that

I had to suddenly relocate to Cali last May after I returned to Hawaii from Japan in March. Long story, but basically for a job offer after my position in Hawaii being obligated to someone else returning from overseas. Thanks for your thoughts.:cheers:

mike100 02-08-2015 12:26 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HAWAIIZR-1 (Post 219731)
I can see that I will have to try to get you to help me to pass when the time comes....

The one saving grace you have is that your car is not yet assigned to any particular zip code and bringing it in-state for the first time will get your target limits assigned to unenhanced area levels (higher limits). The next time will be the enhanced urban area test at the tighter limits though.

Z51JEFF 02-08-2015 03:12 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HAWAIIZR-1 (Post 219731)
I can see that I will have to try to get you to help me to pass when the time comes. I have not even looked into all the stuff I have to replace to pass visual since no C.A.R.B. approved stuff. I did buy a stock air cleaner so far and exhaust manifolds/cats from a 95 take off with 2K miles.

I can help when the time comes.

HAWAIIZR-1 02-08-2015 11:37 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mike100 (Post 219740)
The one saving grace you have is that your car is not yet assigned to any particular zip code and bringing it in-state for the first time will get your target limits assigned to unenhanced area levels (higher limits). The next time will be the enhanced urban area test at the tighter limits though.

Thanks for the info and I have to dive into this more. I know they are going to penalize me for not changing title and all over knowing I brought it in last summer. They want their money (use tax) even if it is sitting in my garage with Hawaii storage title. I thought I might sell it so did not want to bother until I make a decision. Thanks again!:cheers:

HAWAIIZR-1 02-08-2015 11:39 AM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Z51JEFF (Post 219743)
I can help when the time comes.

Thanks for the offer and greatly appreciated. I have a few issues to address when I have some time before I can even think about trying to SMOG it. I wish there was a way to get a test to just see where I am at without them putting the car in the system.

Z51JEFF 02-08-2015 03:34 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
I see on reason why you can't do a pre test. Getting the car to the testing facility is the problem. Use a trailer or get a temp pass from the DMV.

Hib Halverson 02-08-2015 04:54 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KILLSHOTS (Post 219522)
Did you have the power key in the FULL position during the test? If so, you may want to switch to NORMAL and run the test again. Ask me how I know.

Ok. I'll bite.

How does some one from Mesa AZ know you can "pass" the CA Smog Check only with the secondaries disabled.

Hib Halverson 02-08-2015 05:08 PM

Re: Just Failed CA Smog. Now what?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tf95ZR1 (Post 219595)
What's really frustrating is that the pass levels are much tougher now
than when the car was originally designed and built. So how are we
supposed to clean them up? In their minds, this is how they get rid of
the "smog machines".

I agree that the air is MUCH better now than in the 70's, so there has
to be a comprimise. As others have said, if a stock Z is running (really)
well, it should pass, maybe with a few changes/tricks.
With mods is a different story.

"tf95ZR1" gets a "Beacon of Reality" Award.

The reason the max. limits for the Smog Check have been getting incrementally higher is that the State of California wants to drive old cars it believes are "high-polluters" off the road and the 2G ZR-1s are considered "high-polluters". Because there are so few of them, the politicians have nothing to loose by forcing them off the road or out of the State. Sadly, this NOx problem is really tough for 90-92s which lack the EGR valve.

Here are some tips:

Fresh fuel
Clean combustion chambers and piston tops
Stock spark schedule
Proper O2 sensors. I use Densos. I think they are better than Bosch or Delphi. PN 2343005 $28.79 from Rockauto.com
Cats really f'ing hot.
ECT as low as it can get after getting the cats really not

For those with '93-'95 who flunk NOx...buy a revised cal from Marc Haibeck which turns the EGR on at 14-mph rather than 17-mph.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:58 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ZR-1 Net Registry 2025